by Patrick H. Moore

On Friday, the State attorneys prosecuting George Zimmerman for the alleged second-degree- murder of the 17 year old black youth Trayvon Martin called John Good to the witness stand. Good, oddly enough, is expected to be the Zimmerman team’s star witness, their answer to Rachel Jeantel. Good is also one of Zimmerman’s neighbors. He told Sanford police that on the night of the shooting he’d witnessed a black man on top of a lighter-skinned man:

“Just throwing down blows on the guy, MMA-style.”

goodThe prosecution’s strategy in calling Good themselves — knowing full well that his testimony could only undermine their case to an unknown degree — would appear to be the hope that by getting to him first, they could to some degree lessen the damage that will inevitably occur when the defense finally calls him to testify.

Throughout these proceedings, I’ve been waiting for these Floridians to “get their macho on” and today it finally happened, a spirited battle revolving around Combat Sport.

Jeff Weiner and Rene Stutzman of the Orlando Sentinel broke down the parties’ joustings in their Friday evening article:

On the witness stand, Good said he was watching television in the living room of his Retreat at Twin Lakes townhome when he heard noises outside. He opened his glass sliding door and stepped out onto his porch.

It looked like a “tussle,” Good said, adding “I yelled out, ‘What’s going on?’ and ‘Stop it,’ I believe.”

marksAt this point,Good could not resist waxing MMA style, while defense attorney Mark O’Mara acted out Good’s words on his knees in court. Good said he witnessed two people wrestling, in a straddling position, in what in MMA terminology is called the “ground and pound,” which roughly translated means you get the other guy on the ground and then you “pound the sh__ out of him.”

Good stated:

“The one on top was wearing dark clothes and the one on the bottom had lighter skin and was wearing white or red.”

Not one to miss an opportunity, O’Mara asked Good if he could identify them. When Good said he could, O’Mara asked:

“The person who you now know to be Trayvon Martin was on top, correct?”

“Correct,” Good replied.

“And he was the one who was raining blows down on the person on the bottom, George Zimmerman, right?” O’Mara followed.

Good’s response: “That’s what it looked like.”

Although this certainly does not unequivocally prove that Martin attacked Zimmerman, it could certainly serve to offset Rachel Jeantel’s claim that Zimmerman attacked Martin after following him and confronting him.

backGood, however, did vacillate on two points that could benefit the state. He admitted that he wasn’t absolutely certain who was calling out for help — though he thought it was Zimmerman. He also acknowledged that he didn’t see the punches connect; all he saw was “arm movement going downward.”

“I couldn’t tell 100 percent that there was actually fists hitting faces.”

Good also testified that although he witnessed the fight moving onto the sidewalk, “he didn’t see Trayvon slamming Zimmerman’s head (into the sidewalk) as the Neighborhood Watch volunteer described.”

The MMA-style testimony continued in the afternoon with Lindzee Folgate, an Altamonte Family Practice physician assistant, testifying that due to difficulty sleeping, Zimmerman had “started to exercise intensely with MMA” and soon increased his MMA training regimen to “three days per week.”

zimmyFolgate testified that the cuts, scrapes and bruises to Zimmerman’s head could be the result of having his head slammed into a concrete sidewalk.

At one point O’Mara prompted: “Stopping the attack was what allowed him to survive it, wouldn’t you agree?

Folgate initially agreed with O’Mara but admitted that was speculation when questioned by prosecutor Bernie de la Rionda.

***********

Next week lead Sanford police investigator Christopher Serino, the medical examiner who autopsied the Miami Gardens teen, and Trayvon’s parents, Tracy Martin and Sybrina Fulton, will take the witness stand.

***********

Brief Analysis

Based on this week’s testimony, in particular Zimmerman’s 911 dispatch call, a strong argument can be made that  Zimmerman targeted and racially profiled Trayvon Martin. This does not mean, however, that the grounds are there for a second-degree-murder conviction. Under Florida law, second-degree-murder is defined in the following manner:

Murder with a Depraved Mind (Second-Degree-Murder) occurs when a person is killed, without any premeditated design, by an act imminently dangerous to another and evincing a depraved mind showing no regard for human life.

The primary distinction between Premeditated First Degree Murder and Second Degree Murder with a Depraved Mind is that First Degree Murder requires a specific and premeditated intent to kill.

Although I have argued in a previous post that Zimmerman was in a paranoid and highly agitated state of mind, perhaps brought on by ingesting a combination of mind-altering prescription pharmaceuticals, on the night he followed and killed Trayvon Martin, the rach3prosecution does not seem to be pursuing this line of reasoning. Instead, they are trotting out a string of witnesses, none of whom — with the possible exception of Rachel Jeantel — seem to be able to establish conclusively that Zimmerman first attacked Trayvon Martin and then shot and killed him with a single bullet to the chest. Without such evidence, it seemed unlikely that the six member jury will vote unanimously to convict George Zimmerman of second-degree-murder.

Click here to read our previous posts on the George Zimmerman trial:

George Zimmerman Trial: Key State Witness Rachel Jeantel Goes Toe-to-Toe with Zimmerman Defense Team

George Zimmerman Was on a Dangerous Drug Cocktail at Time of Trayvon Martin’s Shooting Death

George Zimmerman Unlikely to Be Convicted of 2nd-Degree Murder

George Zimmerman Trial: Trayvon Martin Death Photos Dominate Day 12

George Zimmerman Trial: Opening Statements Rivet the Nation

George Zimmerman’s Application to Join His Hometown Police Force Was Rejected

Sanford, FL Has a History of Brutal Racial Oppression

 

 

 

 

 

 

2 Responses to George Zimmerman Trial: John Good’s Testimony Is “Good News” For Zimmerman

  1. Marsha Clark made what seemed like a good point on CNN last night — that under Florida law, the aggressor may not claim self defense unless he first makes a clear and concerted effort to stop the fight. Thus the rules are different, depending on who was the aggressor …. and I wonder if, that being the case, if the prosecution is able to establish that Zimmerman was responsible for starting the confrontation, the lowers the bar on what they have to prove in order for it to be murder and not self defense.

    The other thought that keeps occurring to me is . . . reverse everything . . . . imagine George Zimmerman is walking through Trayvon Martin’s neighborhood, and TM is the neighborhood watch guy. Trayvon Martin follows Zimmerman and confronts him, there is a fight, and Trayvon pulls out the gun and kills Zimmerman and calls it self defense.

    How far would Trayvon Martin get with that argument — a black man in a black neighborhood killing a white man in “self defense”?

    • Patrick H. Moore says:

      Michael, you make several good points. I do not believe that the prosecution will be able to prove that Zimmerman physically started the fight, particularly not after John Good’s testimony which seems to establish that Trayvon was getting the best of Zimmerman in the imbroglio. However, there is the issue of proximate cause. If Zimmerman had not followed Martin in the first place, there never would have been an altercation. Martin would still be alive eating skittles and drinking Arizona fruit beverages. I do not know how far back they will take the proximate cause issue, probably not far enough back for the prosecution to effectively use the fact that Zimmerman definitely “started it” in the real sense that he followed Martin in the first place. I think Zimmerman has exposure to manslaughter charges and a potential conviction but, as you know, I don’t think the second-degree-murder evidence is there.

      If Zimmerman was in Trayvon’s neighborhood and Trayvon was the watchman and killed Zimmerman in similar circumstances but in reverse, Trayvon would be in a whole lot of trouble. This is what is commonly known as racism.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:


Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!

Set your Twitter account name in your settings to use the TwitterBar Section.